All posts

What local-first means for your AI chat privacy

By Shaig Khaligli · Updated · 9 min read

Privacy

Any browser extension that works on chatgpt.com, claude.ai, gemini.google.com or grok.com can read what's on those pages, and that includes your conversations. "Local-first" means the extension keeps that data on your device by default and only sends things to a server when there's a specific, stated reason. Before you install one, check four things: the permissions it asks for, what its privacy policy says leaves your browser, what syncs when you sign in, and whether it can change its behavior without an update.

I build TidyChats, an extension that sits on all four of those sites, so I've had to answer these questions about my own product. Below is the plain version: what extensions can technically do, what local-first does and doesn't promise, exactly where TidyChats sends data, and a checklist you can use on any extension, mine included.

What a browser extension on AI sites can actually see

When Chrome shows a warning like "Read and change your data on chatgpt.com" during install, take it literally. An extension with that permission can run code inside the page. It can read every message on screen, read what you type into the chat box before you hit send, and change what the page shows.

It can also make requests to the site using the login you already have. That's how organizer extensions load your chat history without asking for your password: your browser is already signed in, and the extension's requests ride on that session.

So the starting point is that any extension doing something useful on an AI chat site has the technical ability to see your chats. The question that matters is what it does with them afterwards.

What "local-first" means (and what it doesn't)

Local-first is a design choice: your data lives on your device first, and the network is used for specific extras rather than as the default home for everything. For an AI chat extension that usually means transcripts and the search index sit in your browser's own storage, and you can use the core features without an account.

It doesn't mean "nothing ever touches a server." Almost every extension makes some network calls, for license checks, sync, updates or optional AI features. A product can be mostly local and still send certain things out. What you want is a clear list of those exceptions, written down somewhere you can find it.

I'd be wary of any extension that only says "your privacy matters to us" or "we never sell your data." Neither tells you where your chats are stored.

Where TidyChats keeps your data

Here's the full picture for TidyChats as of October 2026, including the parts that go to a server.

TidyChats loads your history the way described above. It never asks for your AI-site passwords, but it does use your existing session to read your chat list and full conversations.

What stays in your browser

  • Chat transcripts, the search index and the media gallery live in your browser's IndexedDB storage on your computer. The in-app wording is "Conversation content and the search index never leave this browser," and that's true for normal use. The two exceptions (AI summaries and ChatGPT search while indexing) are covered below.
  • Folders, prompts, chains, bookmarks, labels, tags, pins and settings are stored in Chrome's local extension storage.
  • Smart tags are applied on your device with keyword matching, not AI. Nothing is sent to a server for tagging.

You don't need an account. Every free feature works without signing in.

What syncs if you sign in

Sync between browsers is part of Premium. With Premium, signing in (email plus a 6-digit code) turns on sync, and "Sync" is on by default once you're signed in. Sync sends your folders, prompts, chains, tags, bookmarks and settings to the TidyChats server so they show up in your other browsers. Chat content does not sync.

Synced items are encrypted at rest on our server, and traffic uses HTTPS. To be precise: this is not end-to-end encryption. The server holds the key, which means it could technically decrypt that data. If your folder names or saved prompts are sensitive (a folder called "Medical" or a prompt that includes client details), keep that in mind, or just don't sign in. Everything except sync and purchases works without an account.

When chat text does leave your browser

  • AI summaries (Premium, signed in). When you use an @@ mention on a chat longer than about 1,200 words, or use "Continue in another AI", the text of that chosen chat (up to 60,000 characters) is sent to the TidyChats server to be summarized. The server uses the OpenAI API when that's configured, and otherwise builds a simple extractive summary itself. Either way, that chat's text goes to our server when you ask for it. Free users, signed-out users and any failed request get a summary built locally in the browser instead. More on how mentions work in the context mentions tutorial.
  • ChatGPT search while indexing is incomplete. ChatGPT limits how fast an extension can read chats, so a big history can take hours to download. Until it's done, your searches are also sent to ChatGPT's own search to fill the gaps. That query goes to OpenAI, which already has the chats, not to us.

Other network calls

  • Leaderboard. If you're signed in, your streak and 30-day message count go to the leaderboard endpoint when you open the Achievements view. They only appear publicly if you opt in with a display name.
  • Anonymous usage statistics. TidyChats counts which features get used (for example "export used" and the format, "new folder", "search") on your device and sends the totals to our server at most every 30 minutes. Each count holds only the event name, platform, extension version, free or Premium, the day and the number, plus a random install id that isn't tied to your account or email (the server stores only a salted hash of it). Chat text, titles, URLs, prompts, folder names, search queries and emails are never sent. It's on by default, and you can turn it off under Settings > Privacy > "Share anonymous usage statistics", which also deletes any unsent counts.
  • Announcements and license checks are fetched from tidychats.com.

Your controls: "Download backup", "Restore from backup", clearing the index per platform, and "Reset everything". The FAQ and features page cover the rest.

A checklist for judging any AI chat extension

Use this on any extension before you give it access to your chats. Nothing here is specific to my product.

1. Read the permissions

On the Chrome Web Store listing, or during install, check which sites it asks for. "Read and change your data on chatgpt.com" is expected for a ChatGPT tool. "Read and change all your data on all websites" is a much bigger ask. Is there a reason a ChatGPT folder tool needs your banking site? Also check whether it wants your browsing history or downloads, and whether the reason is obvious.

2. Find the data section of the privacy policy

Look for answers to three questions: where are transcripts stored, is anything sent to the developer's servers, and which third parties receive data (analytics, AI providers, payment processors)? A good policy names them. If it only says "we take security seriously," treat that as an answer of "unknown."

3. Ask what syncs, and how it's protected

If there's an account, find out exactly what syncs. Is it only your folders and prompts, or full chat content too? Then check the encryption wording carefully. "Encrypted in transit" (HTTPS) is standard. "Encrypted at rest" means the data is encrypted on disk but the company holds the key. "End-to-end encrypted" means only your devices can read it. Those are three different promises, and plenty of marketing copy blurs them.

4. Check for optional AI features

If the extension offers summaries, rewriting or "chat with your history," that text usually goes to a server and often on to an AI provider. Find out whether it's opt-in, what's sent, and which provider gets it.

5. Look for remote code

Chrome's Manifest V3 rules don't allow extensions to run remotely hosted code. Google explains this in its guide to improving extension security. That limits how much an extension can change without a store update. Still, an extension can fetch configuration or "announcements" from its own server, so it's fair to ask what those contain. Prefer extensions that are on Manifest V3 and update through the store.

6. Test the no-account path

If the core features work without signing in, you can try the product before you hand over an email address or any synced data. If an extension needs an account just to show a folder, ask yourself why.

Your AI assistant's own privacy controls matter more

An extension is one layer. The bigger one is the assistant itself, which stores every chat on its servers whatever extension you use. Here are the native controls worth knowing.

ChatGPT. OpenAI's help center says Temporary Chats don't appear in your history and aren't used for training, but may be kept for up to 30 days for safety. Deleted chats are removed from view right away and, per OpenAI's delete and archive article, deleted from its systems within 30 days unless they've been de-identified or must be kept for security or legal reasons. Deleting chats doesn't clear saved memories, which you manage separately (see the memory FAQ).

Gemini. Google's Gemini Apps activity page says activity auto-deletes after 18 months by default. If you turn Keep Activity off, chats are still kept for up to 72 hours. Deleting a chat also removes it from Gemini Apps Activity, per Google's chat management page.

Claude. You can export everything from Settings → Privacy → Export data. Anthropic emails a download link that expires 24 hours after it's created and may work only once, according to its export help page. Export works on the web and the desktop app, not the mobile apps.

Grok. The share button creates a public link to your chat. xAI's FAQ says a link posted publicly may be indexed by search engines, and that you can revoke any link at grok.com/share-links by clicking Remove. If you've shared chats, that page is worth a look.

My take: if a conversation is truly sensitive, the native "temporary" or "activity off" modes do more for your privacy than any extension setting. Use them first.

Questions people ask

Can a Chrome extension read my ChatGPT conversations?

Yes, if it has permission to access chatgpt.com. It can read what's on the page and what you type, and it can use your logged-in session. What it does with that data depends on the developer, which is why the policy and sync details matter.

Does TidyChats upload my chats or sync them encrypted?

Not in normal use. Transcripts and the search index stay in your browser, and chat content doesn't sync at all. Chat text goes to the TidyChats server only when a signed-in Premium user asks for an AI summary of a chosen chat, and ChatGPT search queries go to ChatGPT's own search while your index is still being built. What does sync (folders, prompts, chains, tags, bookmarks and settings) is encrypted at rest on our server, and traffic uses HTTPS, but it isn't end-to-end encrypted: the server holds the key. Sync is a Premium feature, and you can skip it entirely by not signing in.

What's the most private way to use ChatGPT or Gemini?

Use the assistant's own controls: Temporary Chat in ChatGPT, or Keep Activity off in Gemini (chats are still kept up to 72 hours). Then keep extensions to the ones you've checked against the list above. If you use several assistants, my comparison of how to choose between them covers their history and export tools too.

Try TidyChats free

Folders, search and prompts for ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Grok.

Add to Chrome